A couple days ago I had a real hankering for marshmallows. I have no idea why, I was also craving Rice Chex so I don’t think there was rhyme or reason to either said cravings. But alas, I am quite broke from paying bills and didn’t want to go to the store just to buy rice chex and marshmallows. So I decided I’d make them from scratch! …not the rice chex, just the marshmallows. Still waiting for the rice chex craving to mellow out.
But what I thought was going to be a simple and quick recipe to make ended up being the craziest disaster day! I almost gave up a few times, but I conquered the mallow madness.
The first thing you want to do is bloom the gelatin. That was simple and easy, no problems there.
First off, I started with a pot that was apparently way too small. I figured since it only filled the saucepan half way, there was plenty of room for boiling. But no, that was not the case at all. About 6 minutes in, the bubbles started going out of control! The hot sugary liquid quickly boiled over the sides and down onto my stovetop. Quickly, I found a larger pot twice the size of the first one and moved everything into there. The boiling subsided and I waited for the liquid to heat up. Once again, it began to boil over. So I whipped out the biggest soup pot in the house, confident that there would be no way this small amount of liquid boiled over. I have no idea why it was boiling so much and feel like it probably wasn’t supposed to be doing that, but I finally had to call it quits and say the temperature is good enough at 235 degrees F (it was supposed to get to 250) and move on to the next step.
At this point, I have become extremely exasperated. As I put the hot mess that I am sure will not form peaks into the mixer, I decide I’ll add cinnamon in case I messed up the liquid by heating it and cooling it so many times while switching pots. I wasn’t sure if anything had burned so I figured I’d just try to cover up any mistakes with the cinnamon. But then, when I meant to put 1 tablespoon in I accidentally dumped about 3 to 4 good tablespoons in! This is the point where I almost gave up. Feeling defeated, I turned the mixer on high for one last attempt at sanity.

I left the mixer running for about 5 minutes when all of a sudden, the marshmallow cream was advancing over the side of the mixing bowl, as if the world needed to tell me that I had yet to meet my messiness quota for the day. I separated it into three portions and started mixing. And to my surprise, it seemed like it was actually doing what it was supposed to and stiffening to medium peaks! I tasted the marshmallow cream, prepared to spit it out due to the mad crazy amount of cinnamon I dropped in the mixture. But it was delicious! Which is a good thing because otherwise my head probably would have exploded.
So, needless to say, I recommend starting by either only making half of this recipe or having a very large pot at hand. I’m interested to see if anybody tries this recipe and has the same problems I did with the boiling over.
And because I got so many questions from friends, YES they are just like “real” (ahem, store-bought!) marshmallows, YES you can toast them over a fire and make smores, YES you can put them in your hot cocoa! : )
Cinnamon Marshmallows
1-1/4 oz (5 packets) gelatin, granulated
2 c cold water
1lb 8oz sugar
12 oz light corn syrup
12 oz honey
1 TB vanilla extract
1 to 3 TB cinnamon (depending on how strong you want the cinnamon flavor to be)
confectioner’s sugar, for cutting
Bloom the gelatin in 1 cup of the water.
Combine the sugar, corn syrup, honey, and rest of the water in a large pot or saucepan. Bring to a boil over high heat, stirring constantly to ensure that the sugar fully dissolves. Allow to boil without stirring until the temperature reaches between 230 degrees and 252 degrees F.
Allow to cool to 210 degrees F while you remelt the gelatin (you can do this by putting it in the microwave for about 20 to 30 seconds). Stir the vanilla into the gelatin and then stir the gelatin mixture into the syrup. Now add the cinnamon and mixture into your mixer and whip on high speed until medium peaks form.
After lining a sheet pan with parchment paper, spread the marshmallow cream evenly into the sheet pan. Allow to set before cutting, at least 4 hours.
To cut, remove the set marshmallow from the sheet pan, inverting it onto a work surface sprinkled with powdered sugar and peel off the paper. Cut into small squares, dusting with confectioner’s sugar as necessary to keep from sticking.
Enjoy in hot cocoa, s’mores, or by themselves!


























Recent Comments